Thread Rating:
  • 0 Votes - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Is Patient-Centered Medicine Bad For Overall Health Care Quality?

Post: #1
06-27-2010, 01:05 AM
member9816 Offline

Is Patient-Centered Medicine Bad For Overall Health Care Quality?

Health care gets a reasonable share of media coverage in countries like Canada, Australia and the UK where governments manage the system and are ultimately accountable to the population. However, in the US, the level of national media coverage has risen significantly since the start of the debates and political battles associated with the health reform bill that was ultimately passed there roughly two months ago. In the latest news, a study from The Commonwealth Fund ranked the health care systems of a number of countries.

Although the placement of the US in last position amongst this list of 7 countries received considerable media attention in the US and abroad, there are a number of other important observations that can be made and questions that arise from the results of this study. Some of the most interesting come from observing the individual rankings of the two laggards within the study, namely Canada and US, because of their very different health care systems.

In Canada, the health care system is socialized, is completely supported by tax dollars, and provides care to the entire population. The Federal government sets standards and strategy and provides some funding but the provinces administer and deliver the health care services. To over simplify, a tenet of the health care system in Canada is about providing security and equity of access.

In contrast, the health system in the US is based on a mix of private health insurance, public health coverage for some eligible citizens, not-for-profit health providers, private health providers and some government assistance for those at the bottom of the financial spectrum. State governments have been largely responsible for health strategy and regulation of deliver. The system is not a centrally organized health care system. To over simplify once more, the tenets of the US health care system are freedom of choice and ability to access the best care one can personally afford.

Given these differences in implementation, it was interesting to see both scoring so poorly in comparison to the other countries. Quite clearly neither of these systems is serving their respective populations as well as they could.

During the health care reform debate in the US, those in opposition to the reforms repeatedly commented on the horrible inefficiencies of the government-run medical systems of both the UK and Canada, two countries with nationalized health care systems. Much of the commentary was uninformed, partisan in nature and supported by only select news clippings appearing during the debate.

Despite this, the point that was trying to be made was that since the US Federal government has been observed as being inefficient in running other departments and programs, they would do a no better job being involved in health care.

While such a statement cannot be generalized, in the case of Canada, there may be some truth to the commentary regarding the ineffectiveness of government-run health care as the country had the second highest spending, but the least effective treatment and the least timely delivery of care. However, such inefficiency was definitely not demonstrated in the UK where treatment effectiveness was first among all 7 countries, timely delivery of care was middle of the pack, but costs in the UK were 40% of those in the US and roughly 75% of those in Canada.

Quite clearly, the differences in operation of the Canadian and US systems does not fully account for the poor delivery of health care delivered by each. If the differences between the systems in these two countries are not as important, then maybe the similarities might be in factors explaining the shared poor performance.

One such common factor that might contribute to the poor overall score in both Canada and the US is the significant decentralization of health care management and delivery by the provinces in Canada and by the states and individual health care providers in the Us. With different management in each state and province, there is administrative overlap, less coordinated attempts to adopt best practices from other regions and reduced ability to achieve economies of scale in purchases.

Another common aspect of the two systems can been seen in a very interesting finding from The Commonwealth Fund study. The study results show that two countries that had the worst ranking in patient-centered care were also those that had the best overall ranking. Canada and the US on the other hand had middle of the pack rankings in this regard. The question that arises here is whether patient-centered care impedes the ability to deliver efficient, quality care?

It is not hard to imagine that this might be the case. While involving patients in their health care is considered an important goal, there are implications that could result.

Informing a patient and their family regarding patient health and the decision-making process is definitely time consuming for health care practitioners. Listening to patients to find out which treatments best suit them is as well. Keeping family members well informed regarding the health of patient also takes effort. Any of these factors could result in less timely and less effective care. Ultimately, allowing patients to make important, informed decisions in the process could very well reduce the ability to give the best medical care.

As far as equity of care is concerned, patient-centered care might also affect this quality of care. It is quite easy to conceive that with such a model, the differences in care delivered to a patient with actively involved family members could be much better than the care delivered to a patient whose family is more passive. Such family influences would mean that the equity of care could be affected. If family members and patients are less involved in treatment decisions, the system must make the decisions and whether good or bad would likely make the decisions more consistently.

Similarly, patient-centered care might also affect the ability to deliver safe and coordinated care. Time spent interacting with the patient could mean less time is available and less focus is directed toward performing the medicine required to treat the patient safely. Mistakes could be made because attention is not entirely focused on treatment. This might also affect coordination of care because involving the patient in the process could slow down and impede the ability to maintain coordination among the health care providers.

All of these are just ideas however, but ideas that might be worth researching further.

For countries like the US and Canada, the findings of the study unfortunately highlight the ability of either a socialized health care system such as Canada's or a for-profit system such as the US's to provide relatively poor health care. This means that getting good care cannot be boiled down to a simplified argument of private versus socialist health care. Many countries with socialist care or a mix of socialist and for-profit health care did better than these two countries with their respective systems on the opposite ends of the spectrum.

However, maybe the model of patient-centered care needs to be assessed. While it is certainly a feel-good approach, the inclusion of additional parties in the process might impede the ability of the system to treat patients and as a result this goal may need to be rethought.

Related Links


Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post: #2
05-09-2014, 04:25 PM
member49983 Offline

RE: Is Patient-Centered Medicine Bad For Overall Health Care Quality?

I believe that I understand your line of reasoning with this post; however I was interested in what the alternative was. If patient-centered medicine weighs the already complex US healthcare system, what would an alternative look like?

I also believe that technology and culture have a role in all of this too. If you combine the American belief in individualism and personal choice then combine that with the increase of medical content being pushed them, you have the recipe for a complex and patient-centered health care system.

Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post: #3
05-24-2016, 08:06 AM
member49510 Offline

RE: Is Patient-Centered Medicine Bad For Overall Health Care Quality?

I feel that it should be the base for everything. I mean, medicine has to be patient based or else what are we doing? Medicine exists to make people healthy, not to generate profit, our focus should be there.

Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post: #4
04-13-2017, 05:17 AM
member9106 Offline

RE: Is Patient-Centered Medicine Bad For Overall Health Care Quality?

let >minnesota timberwolves jersey</strong> him <strong>coach bags outlet</strong> know <strong>sacramento kings</strong> the <strong>air max thea</strong> results <strong>www.tommyhilfiger.nl</strong> of <strong>longchamp outlet</strong> a <strong>toms shoes outlet</strong> crystal <strong>true religion outlet</strong> shop <strong>miami heat</strong> owner, <strong>burberry outlet</strong> he <strong>mcm backpack</strong> followed <strong>timberland</strong> "a <strong>air max</strong> person <strong>swarovski crystal</strong> closer <strong>juicy couture</strong> dream, <strong>nj jerseys</strong> destiny became <strong>toms shoes outlet</strong> more <strong>salomon schuhe</strong> and <strong>kate spade</strong> more <strong>vans shoes</strong> into <strong>burberry outlet online</strong>Taishan <strong>nike fu?ballschuhe</strong> collapse <strong>jaguars jerseys</strong> in <strong>timberland boots</strong> the <strong>michael kors outlet</strong> former and <strong>longchamp</strong>without <strong>cheap nike shoes</strong> blinking <strong>coach purses outlet</strong> an <strong>denver nuggets jerseys</strong> eye, <strong>portland trail blazers jersey</strong> thousands <strong>michael kors handbags</strong> of <strong>steelers jerseys</strong> people, <strong>cheap jerseys</strong> such <strong>nike running shoes</strong> as <strong>vikings jerseys</strong> unhindered. <strong>coach black friday</strong> Win <strong>coach factory online</strong> without <strong>coach outlet sale</strong> pride, <strong>north face</strong> lose <strong>rams jerseys</strong> with <strong>hornets jersey</strong>grace. <strong>north face canada</strong> A <strong>burberry sale</strong> man, <strong>michael kors handbags</strong> if <strong>hermes outlet</strong> life <strong>adidas</strong> and <strong>barbour womens jackets</strong> death, <strong>chiefs jerseys</strong> indifferent, <strong>nike soccer shoes</strong> Dankan <strong>ralph lauren online shop</strong> gains <strong>replica watches</strong> and <strong>longchamp</strong> losses <strong>new balance outlet</strong> tend <strong>easton bats</strong> to <strong>polo ralph lauren</strong> be <strong>nike air max</strong> a <strong>prada handbags</strong> survivor, <strong>nike.com</strong> get a <strong>michael kors handbags</strong> windfall. There <strong>beats audio</strong> is <strong>michael kors outlet online sale</strong> a <strong>coach shop</strong> story <strong>ralph lauren polo</strong> that <strong>nike running</strong> a <strong>cheap oakley sunglasses</strong> selling <strong>detroit pistons</strong> bean <strong>warriors jerseys</strong> curd, <strong>veneta</strong> and <strong>oakley sunglasses cheap</strong> suddenly <strong>montre homme</strong> unexpectedly received <strong>handbags outlet</strong> challenge <strong>coach usa</strong> a <strong>polo ralph lauren</strong> warrior, <strong>hollisterco</strong> lives <strong>burberry sale</strong> are <strong>soccer shoes</strong> at <strong>michael kors</strong> stake. <strong>converse sneakers</strong> He <strong>michael kors australia</strong> asked <strong>ray ban outlet</strong> a <strong>philipp plein clothing</strong> Zen <strong>oakley sunglasses</strong> master <strong>mcm bags</strong> to <strong>gafas oakley</strong> save <strong>long champ</strong> his <strong>hogan sito ufficiale</strong> life, <strong>titans jerseys</strong> Jackson <strong>hollister clothing</strong> taught <strong>coach outlet online</strong> him <strong>new balance</strong> to <strong>north face jackets</strong> calm <strong>true religion jeans men</strong> down, <strong>michael kors</strong> not <strong>polo ralph lauren outlet</strong> to <strong>red bottom</strong> fight as <strong>coach factory outlet online</strong> a <strong>bcbg max azria</strong> duel, <strong>ralph lauren</strong> as <strong>new balance</strong> tofu <strong>ed hardy clothing</strong> can <strong>nba jerseys</strong> be. <strong>ray ban outlet</strong> Time <strong>mbt womens shoes</strong> to <strong>roshe run</strong> duel, saw <strong>the north face outlet</strong> Maidou <strong>azcardinals jerseys</strong> Fu <strong>mizuno running shoes</strong> calmly, <strong>dre beats</strong> gently <strong>nike schoenen</strong> hats <strong>coach outlet</strong> off, <strong>ralph lauren</strong> on <strong>oakley</strong> the <strong>converse outlet</strong> bench. <strong>coach bags outlet</strong> Do <strong>dre headphones</strong> not <strong>michael kors outlet online</strong> hurry <strong>oakley outlet</strong> hurry, <strong>hollister online</strong> slowly <strong>burberry</strong>untied <strong>rolex replica</strong> robe, <strong>jimmy choo</strong> lightly <strong>nike.se</strong> dust <strong>designer handbags</strong> shells <strong>babyliss flat iron</strong> robes, <strong>cheap shoes</strong> folded carefully <strong>true religion jeans outlet</strong> and <strong>nba jerseys</strong> slowly <strong>polo ralph lauren</strong> on <strong>ralph lauren black friday</strong> the <strong>ralph lauren outlet</strong> bench, <strong>milwaukee bucks jersey</strong> then <strong>louboutin</strong> went <strong>giuseppe zanotti</strong> over <strong>instyler ionic styler</strong> to <strong>chi flat iron</strong> faint,<strong>versace outlet</strong> slowly <strong>hollister co</strong> pulled <strong>adidas online shop</strong> out <strong>coach outlet usa</strong> a <strong>coach outlet</strong> long <strong>prada outlet</strong> knife, <strong>prada tracksuits</strong> even <strong>vans schuhe</strong> in <strong>asics gel</strong> the <strong>christian louboutin shoes</strong> eye <strong>nike free run</strong> did <strong>falcons jerseys</strong> not <strong>jordan shoes</strong>see the <strong>michael kors outlet</strong> warrior <strong>beats by dre headphones</strong> a. Suddenly, <strong>nike huarache</strong> the <strong>washington wizards jersey</strong>warrior <strong>cheap jerseys</strong> splash, <strong>stephen curry shoes</strong> knees, <strong>buccaneers jerseys</strong> and <strong>kate spade</strong> dropped <strong>michael kors</strong> the <strong>cheap basketball shoes</strong> hands <strong>giuseppe zanotti sneakers</strong> of <strong>polo outlet store</strong> the <strong>burberry outlet store</strong> knife. Samurai <strong>jordan shoes</strong>by <strong>replica watches</strong> his calm <strong>uhren shop</strong> and <strong>nike store uk</strong> relaxed <strong>north face backpacks</strong> overawed, <strong>pandora charms</strong> utterly <strong>jordans for sale</strong> demoralized. <strong>michael kors bags</strong> So <strong>jordan retro</strong> calm, <strong>replica watches</strong> it must <strong>michael kors uk</strong> be <strong>abercrombie</strong>world <strong>eagles jerseys</strong> outside <strong>ray-ban sunglasses</strong> expert! <strong>toms.com</strong> In <strong>prada shoes</strong> fact, <strong>levis jeans</strong> we <strong>tommy hilfiger</strong> are<strong>oakley sunglasses</strong> often <strong>bulls jerseys</strong> lost <strong>northface</strong> their <strong>cheap jerseys</strong> own, so <strong>mavericks jerseys</strong> that <strong>dsquared2 outlet</strong> we <strong>cowboys jerseys</strong> fail, <strong>tory burch</strong> the <strong>panthers jerseys</strong> outcome <strong>adidas sneakers</strong> is <strong>hermes belt</strong> sinking <strong>ray ban pas cher</strong>heart.Calm <strong>nike store</strong> and <strong>prada outlet</strong> quiet, <strong>adidas.se</strong> it <strong>kate spade bags</strong> is <strong>colts jerseys</strong> a <strong>giants jerseys</strong> realm <strong>oakley frogskins</strong> of <strong>soccer shoes outlet</strong> life, is <strong>wedding dress</strong> a <strong>retro jordans</strong> life <strong>nike roshe run</strong> attitude. <strong>swarovski australia</strong>Northern <strong>nike air max thea</strong> Song <strong>oakley sunglasses cheap</strong> Wenhao <strong>toms outlet online</strong> Dongpo, <strong>nike air max</strong> and <strong>toms shoes</strong>Jackson <strong>oakley sunglasses</strong> Foyin <strong>nike store</strong> are <strong>lions jerseys</strong> good friends. <strong>christian louboutin</strong> One <strong>new balance</strong> day, <strong>cheap jerseys</strong> he <strong>michael kors purses</strong> enlightened, <strong>ray ban sunglasses</strong> realize <strong>purses and handbags</strong> "eight <strong>rayban</strong> wind <strong>coach outlet store</strong> does <strong>prada</strong> not <strong>mcm handbags</strong> move," <strong>hugo boss outlet online</strong> the <strong>houston rockets</strong> Zen, <strong>atlanta hawks jerseys</strong> very <strong>cheap oakley sunglasses</strong> proud, <strong>oakley sunglasses</strong> immediately <strong>jets jerseys</strong> brush <strong>chargers jerseys</strong> to <strong>timberland outlet</strong> write <strong>adidas superstar</strong> these <strong>ray bans</strong> five <strong>louboutin shoes</strong> words. <strong>pandora bracelet</strong> Busy <strong>the north face</strong> nunnery <strong>michael kors</strong> sent <strong>barbour mens jackets</strong> the <strong>longchamp handbags</strong> word to <strong>eyeglasses stores</strong> the <strong>oakley</strong> other <strong>true religion outlet</strong> side <strong>ray ban wayfarer</strong> of <strong>burberry outlet online</strong> the <strong>redskins jerseys</strong> river <strong>raiders jerseys</strong> there <strong>celine outlet</strong> Foyin correction. <strong>coach factory outlet online</strong> After <strong>hermes birkin bag</strong> Yin <strong>oakley sunglasses</strong> see <strong>cheap oakley sunglasses</strong> below <strong>michael kors handbags</strong> Phi <strong>givenchy shoes outlet</strong> a <strong>rayban</strong> word: <strong>roshes</strong> fart. <strong>thomas sabo uk</strong> Sushi <strong>barbour jackets</strong> annoyed <strong>true religion jeans women</strong>by <strong>converse shoes</strong> boat <strong>ralph lauren outlet online</strong> across <strong>air max</strong> the <strong>nike roshe run</strong> river <strong>ray ban wayfarer</strong> to <strong>north face outlet</strong> the <strong>michael kors outlet</strong> theory. Yin <strong>barbour jackets</strong> indifferent <strong>rolex watches</strong> smile, <strong>hoodies store</strong> said: <strong>purses and handbags</strong> "Eight <strong>ferragamo shoes</strong> wind <strong>ralph lauren</strong> does <strong>nike air force</strong> not <strong>new orleans pelicans jersey</strong> move, <strong>puma shoes outlet</strong> across <strong>oakley sunglasses outlet</strong> the <strong>replica rolex</strong> river <strong>nike running shoes</strong> to <strong>spurs jerseys</strong> a fart." <strong>patriots jerseys</strong>Dongpo <strong>puma online shop</strong> several <strong>mcm handbags</strong> ups <strong>nike air max</strong> and <strong>air max 90</strong> downs <strong>cheap nfl jerseys</strong> in <strong>juicy couture outlet</strong> politics, <strong>ray ban sunglasses outlet</strong> after <strong>hollister co</strong> the <strong>north face jackets</strong> low <strong>ray ban zonnebril</strong> life, <strong>celtics jersey</strong>awareness <strong>ray ban outlet</strong> of <strong>christian louboutin uk</strong> this <strong>tory burch sandals</strong> life <strong>49ers jerseys</strong> is <strong>nike.dk</strong> meant <strong>pandora jewellery australia</strong> to <strong>nike tn</strong> be <strong>rayban</strong> light, <strong>rolex watches</strong> become <strong>lunette ray ban</strong> chic <strong>toronto raptors jersey</strong> -. <strong>the north face</strong> "Mo <strong>nike air max</strong> listen <strong>memphis grizzlies jersey</strong> Chuan <strong>bills jerseys</strong> Lin beat <strong>nike blazers</strong> Ye, <strong>coach outlet online</strong> why <strong>bottega veneta</strong> Yin Xiao <strong>new balance shoes</strong> and <strong>nike roshe run</strong> Xing <strong>cheap ray ban</strong> Xu <strong>adidas superstar</strong> Zhu <strong>polo ralph lauren outlet online</strong> Zhang <strong>indiana pacers jersey</strong> Mans <strong>nike huarache</strong> shoes <strong>pandora</strong> light <strong>longchamp outlet</strong> horse , who's <strong>seahawks jerseys</strong> afraid? <strong>cavaliers jersey</strong> Yisuoyanyu Renping <strong>montblanc</strong> Sheng. <strong>nfl jerseys</strong> "Every <strong>michael kors outlet online sale</strong> ordinary <strong>burberry outlet online</strong> people, <strong>calvin klein outlet</strong> more <strong>michael kors outlet online</strong> than <strong>nike air max</strong> half <strong>nike free 5.0</strong> of <strong>longchamp taschen</strong> the <strong>rolex</strong> road <strong>asics</strong> of <strong>marc by marc jacobs</strong> life <strong>ferragamo</strong> is <strong>red bottom</strong> wind <strong>toms outlet</strong> and <strong>ravens jerseys</strong> rain, <strong>ecco shoes outlet</strong> most <strong>saints jerseys</strong> of <strong>swarovski jewelry</strong> the <strong>zapatillas nike</strong> ups <strong>burberry</strong> and <strong>burberry online shop</strong> downs. <strong>salvatore ferragamo</strong> Only <strong>nike air max</strong> calm <strong>tommy hilfiger outlet</strong> in <strong>michael kors</strong> the <strong>longchamp handbags</strong> face, <strong>sunglasses for women</strong> accept <strong>ipad mini cases</strong> it, <strong>relojes</strong> I <strong>air max</strong> do <strong>coach outlet online</strong> not <strong>burberry outlet store</strong> feel <strong>burberry handbags outlet</strong> bitter. <strong>texans jerseys</strong> The <strong>polo outlet online</strong> bitter <strong>coach bags outlet</strong> life, <strong>bcbg max</strong> not<strong>michael kors v?skor</strong> afraid <strong>bears jerseys</strong> to <strong>ray ban sunglasses</strong> have <strong>packers jerseys</strong> a <strong>pandora charms</strong> bitter <strong>tommy hilfiger canada</strong> heart, <strong>suns jersey</strong> in <strong>burberry</strong> order <strong>broncos jerseys</strong> to taste <strong>toms shoes outlet</strong> the <strong>fivefingers</strong> bitter <strong>barbour jacket outlet</strong> to <strong>ray ban uk</strong> sweet <strong>adidas yeezy shoes</strong> taste. <strong>polo ralph lauren</strong> Since <strong>utah jazz jersey</strong> ancient <strong>chrome hearts rings</strong>times, Huashan, <strong>cheap michael kors</strong> a <strong>marc by marc jacobs</strong> road, <strong>lacoste shirts</strong> trail in <strong>celine outlet</strong> the <strong>air jordan retro</strong> cliffs that <strong>timberland outlet</strong> can <strong>browns jerseys</strong> be <strong>supra footwear</strong> chic <strong>swarovski</strong> Xu <strong>thomas sabo</strong> line <strong>los angeles lakers</strong> for <strong>ray bans</strong> you, <strong>oakley</strong> and <strong>lac jersey</strong> how <strong>nike factory</strong> many? <strong>cheap oakley</strong> "Paper <strong>cheap jerseys</strong> come <strong>ralph lauren factory store</strong> I <strong>iphone 4s cases</strong> felt <strong>ralph lauren polo</strong> light, <strong>swarovski online shop</strong> must <strong>kate spade handbags</strong> know <strong>hilfiger outlet</strong> this <strong>armani outlet online</strong> practice <strong>michael kors</strong> is <strong>nike air huarache</strong> essential." <strong>converse chucks</strong> Read <strong>michael kors bags</strong> a <strong>polo outlet</strong> lot <strong>bengals jerseys</strong> better <strong>dsquared2</strong> than <strong>ny jersey</strong> reading <strong>oakley sunglasses</strong> ten <strong>pandora canada</strong> thousand <strong>hilfiger online shop</strong> books, <strong>76ers jerseys</strong> Zen <strong>michael kors outlet</strong> Hui <strong>nike roshe run</strong> Neng, <strong>adidas zx flux</strong> illiterate, <strong>michael jordan</strong>able <strong>red bottom shoes</strong> to <strong>cheap michael kors</strong> deep <strong>adidas shoes</strong> understanding <strong>dolphins jerseys</strong> of <strong>air jordan shoes</strong> nature, <strong>burberry outlet store</strong> calm <strong>michael kors purses</strong> on <strong>okc jerseys</strong> the <strong>polo ralph</strong> road, <strong>nike shoes</strong> we <strong>jimmy choo outlet</strong> can say, <strong>tommy hilfiger online</strong> road <strong>ralph lauren outlet online</strong> in <strong>swarovski crystal</strong> life, <strong>valentino outlet</strong> in <strong>philipp plein</strong>nature.Reading <strong>womens clothing</strong> philosophical <strong>vans outlet</strong> Essay, <strong>michael kors uhren</strong> the <strong>orlando magic jersey</strong> maximum <strong>tory burch sandals</strong> sentence <strong>nike free</strong> is read: <strong>easton bats</strong> "Rain <strong>toms shoes outlet</strong> or <strong>omega watches</strong> shine, <strong>chi hair</strong> see <strong>nike mercurial vapor</strong> Pretrial blossom; fate <strong>reebok</strong> not, <strong>airmax</strong> look <strong>p90x3</strong> Yunjuanyunshu <strong>ray ban occhiali</strong> air." <strong>tory burch handbags</strong>In <strong>fendi</strong> fact, <strong>nfl jerseys</strong> Tao <strong>mcm handbags</strong> is <strong>woolrich womens jackets</strong> very <strong>hogan</strong> simple, <strong>air max 2014</strong> life <strong>oakley sunglasses outlet</strong> is <strong>hollister</strong> very <strong>nfl jerseys</strong>
<strong><a href="http://www.true-religion-jeans.com.co/">true religion</a


Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 


Copyright 2007-2018 Chaotic Inceptions - Wellescent.com