| July 10th, 2009 | |
 |
Though many of us looking to improve and maintain our health may use supplements on a regular basis, we often do so without any guarantee as to whether these alternative medicinal products provide any positive benefit at all. When it comes to patients with more serious diseases or cancers, the use of alternative medicines in combination with or as a replacement to accepted medicines becomes more risky. This is simply because the effects of these alternative medicines and the possible interactions with other accepted medicines is frequently unknown.
The use of alternative medicines often has a polarizing effect among people including doctors because while some trust the strong historical and anecdotal evidence for the effectiveness of the these natural medicines, others are not convinced until a full-blown scientific study is performed. One of the credibility problems associated with well-known traditional remedies is the effect of too many benefits being associated with a single "medicine". Both the "old-wives" and snake-oil salesmen alike will often claim one hundred and one benefits to a given product. The thought process seems to be that if it gets rid of my stomachache, it must cure cancer too, not to mention eliminating wrinkles.
On top of this credibility problem, alternative medicines are usually made from readily available sources with that being how their benefits became known in the first place. This poses a problem because of the nature of the pharmaceutical business. Pharmaceutical companies spend large numbers of dollars to develop their medicines and to run them through the series of clinical trials to prove that they are effective. They do so with patents protecting their research and development to give them the best chance to make siginficant profits from their investment.
As a result, if there is no patentable research for a product, then there is no incentive for a pharmaceutical company to run through all the phases of clinical trials in order to prove that a readily available material has health benefits. Some other company would simply be able to start making the same product without having to invest in the research and testing. The net result of this is that even if an alternative medicine does show some inkling of medicinal properties, only limited efforts are possible to prove this.
This does not keep the public from getting these alternative medicines, but simply prevents them from knowing whether the products are effective since many companies still make a lot of money selling the herbal and other alternative medicinal products, but without officially stating the benefit that the product may offer. Though good for the sellers of the supplements, herbs and extracts, this leaves the public largely at the mercy of the "old-wives" and snake-oil salesmen for their information gathering, even more so with the advent of the Internet.
Although doing so with limited funding, a number of universities and medical research organizations are doing the hard work of analyzing some traditional and alternative remedies with the required scientific vigor of the same double-blind placebo-controlled procedures that the pharmaceutical companies must use. The double-blind drug trial with use of a placebo means that all the patients in the trial are given either the drug being tested or something like a sugar pill with no medicinal value. At the same time neither the patient taking the pill nor the doctor providing the pill know whether it is the real drug or not. This form of trial is the best at ensuring that nobody involved in the trial can manipulate the results.
As can be expected, many of the claims made for alternative remedies are being disproved, but some are showing value in treating specific conditions. In many cases, because of the baggage associated with some untested alternative "medicines", researchers have a large number of tests that they can run for the various claims against a given "medicine". The one good thing about testing products that people have been taking for a while is that generally, they are not highly toxic with a host of unknown side effects that would required lengthy animal testing. The unfortunate part is that these researchers cannot generally run studies with large numbers of participants because of the costs. The result is that the same trials must be run by a number of organizations in order to gain sufficient credibility.
So while mangosteen, green tea, grape seed extract, melatonin, ginger extract, lycopene from tomatoes, various antioxidants and resveratrol from red wine are all being actively promoted online in various formats to treat a variety of ills, the facts surrounding these possible natural remedies are taking time to develop. If it makes you feel good, there is nothing wrong in taking many of the supplements. However, if you have a medical condition, let your doctor know just what other alternative medicines your taking just the same way you would if you were taking the accepted medicines. It is also a good idea to support the efforts of the universities financially, because in those cases where the researchers do confirm the benefits of an alternative medicine, we will all benefit.
What alternative remedies would you like to see trialled to see if they are effective?
Related Links:
http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=1293925 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alternative_medicine http://www.mendosa.com/bratman.htm http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/ http://www.mbmc.org/healthgate/GetHGContent.aspx?token=9c315661-83b7-472d-a7ab-bc8582171f86&chunkiid=21805#ref32 http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/53459.php http://pt.wkhealth.com/pt/re/bjui/abstract.00002414-199805000-00016.htm;jsessionid=KVlbxnbJpmyhhwJc3CYywS7dyLLkbjlT3tGZy7Ln62JB7N5GjX0y!1109661354!181195629!8091!-1 http://healthlibrary.epnet.com/GetContent.aspx?token=e0498803-7f62-4563-8d47-5fe33da65dd4&chunkiid=21738 http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S1542356506008007 http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/7803619.stm http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT00654667
|
|
| tags | alternative medicine mainstream medicine drug trials |
|
|
| tag cloud | risk infection research obesity care heart disease stroke medical depression medical research pain health cancer seniors stress drugs aging |
Comments - good commentary on the articles is much appreciated
|
| Robin - July 11th, 2009 at 7:49 |
| It's so true that drug companies fund most research into medicines, so therefor vitamins etc don't get studied. | |
|
| onthewards - July 12th, 2009 at 1:19 |
This is a good informational article for public awareness. Unfortunately, when the general consumer sees a bottle at their local drugstore with all the fancy images and flashing fonts claiming to heal all evil humors, one assumes that the appropriate research has been performed to back these claims.
As a consolation, although Big Pharma may not be willing to test non-proprietary compounds, there is at least some interest within academia to test some of them. For the past half-month alone, there have been nearly 40 peer-reviewed journal articles published on green tea and its compounds. Not too shabby. | |
|
| member1 - July 13th, 2009 at 12:44 |
Its good to see such figures on green tea research and though we are far from that time at present, it will be nice to see a time when many of the previous alternative medicines have been properly credited for what they really offer and discredited from the inaccurate claims made against them.
| |
|
| surgery thailand - July 14th, 2009 at 1:10 |
| Yes drug companies are not the saints they make out anymore, its all about the momenyt and the greed. ALl the ancient remedies and chinese wisdom in the world is slipping away from the present. How far do we have to burn before we learn??? | |
|
|
|
| February 4th, 2010 | |
While not getting a good night[[sq]]s sleep will make most of us a little less focused and potentially a little cranky, some problems associated with poor sleep are actually dangerous. Sleep apnea is one such condition that increases the risks of other health disorders. |
| tags | sleep apnea OSA CSA sleep disorder fatigue heart attack high blood pressure health forums |
|
| January 29th, 2010 | |
With few symptoms in most cases, aneurysms are a form of "silent killer" that can sneak up on victims causing death or severe disability. However, when successfully diagnosed, such conditions can be treated with considerable success. |
| tags | aneurysm aneurism abdominal aortic aneurysm thoracic aortic aneurysm brain aneurysm stomach aneurysm |
|
| January 24th, 2010 | |
When it comes to Hepatitis C, we have been fortunate to see a decrease in infection rates of the disease for quite a number of years. Unfortunately, a lack of focus on managing the disease now threatens to increase the health costs for the condition. |
| tags | hepatitis hepatitis C viral infection disease prevention antiviral liver cancer |
|
| January 19th, 2010 | |
As far as medical technologies go, the bandages is not something that most of us would consider when thinking about advanced medicine. However, with much research being directed at creating a better bandage, we will soon be looking at bandages in a whole new light. |
| tags | bandage infection wound healing gauze adhesive diabetic ulcer medical research health forums |
|
| January 14th, 2010 | |
As the death toll in Haiti continues to climb, the media will focus considerable attention on the number of dead. While the deaths are a tragedy, it is important to remember the plight of the survivors and the health risks that they will face over the upcoming days and months. |
| tags | disaster injuries crushing injuries natural disasters PTSD shock |
|
|